Mamata Banerjee Criticizes Modi Government’s Waqf Bill, Calls It Anti-Federal and Anti-Secular

Mamata Banerjee Criticizes Modi Government’s Waqf Bill, Calls It Anti-Federal and Anti-Secular

Tamal Saha     Nov 28, 2024 12:21 pm

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee sharply criticized the Central Government’s proposed amendments to the Waqf Act, 1995, calling it an attack on federalism, secularism, and the rights of minority communities. The bill, which aims to increase accountability in the management of Waqf boards, proposes significant changes, including the mandatory inclusion of Muslim women and non-Muslims in these bodies.

Speaking in the West Bengal Assembly, Banerjee expressed her opposition to the bill, saying the state government had not been consulted on the changes. “The state government has not been consulted at all,” she remarked, adding that such a major issue should involve input from state governments that manage Waqf boards.

The Chief Minister warned that if the bill becomes law, it would effectively “destroy” the institution of Waqf, which has existed since British colonial times. “Waqf properties also have Hindus residing in them, and some properties have been donated by other communities. These are shared resources,” Banerjee said, underlining the historical and pluralistic nature of Waqf institutions.
Banerjee also criticized the bill’s centralization of power over Waqf boards, describing it as “anti-federal.” She called it a deliberate attempt to “malign a particular section” and deprive Muslims of their rights. “In this bill, the rights of Muslims are being snatched away,” she stated, drawing attention to how the bill seeks to alter the governance structure of Waqf boards without sufficient consultation with stakeholders.

The contentious bill was proposed to be taken up during the winter session but sources indicate, there could be appeal made on Friday by the Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) which is in custody of the bill, seeking extension of time till the last day of the budget session of 2025. The come following a stormy meeting of the panel marked by a brief walkout from opposition members on November 27 over disagreements.

On the issue of alleged atrocities against Hindus in Bangladesh, Mamata Banerjee expressed solidarity with those affected, stating, “We cannot tolerate atrocities against any community.” She referred to her conversations with religious leaders in Bengal, including the ISKCON head, and reiterated that her government supports the central government in addressing international issues, particularly related to what’s unfolding in Bangladesh. “I have spoken to the ISKCON head here in Kolkata. We can’t tolerate any atrocity against any community. But Bangladesh is a different country and the Government of India has to take a decision. Whatever the Union Government decides we will support it. There’s no difference on this. We will not tolerate any atrocity against community” she added in the backdrop of arrest of priest Chinmoy Krishna Das in Bangladesh that has stoked diplomatic tensions between India and Bangladesh -the two neighbours.


While she stressed on solidarity with the people affected in Bangladesh, but Banerjee equally stressed on the need for domestic policies to reflect India’s commitment to secularism. “If there’s any atrocity against any community in another country, we speak about. So why should we not speak it, if happening in our own country” Mamata Banerjee questioned while suggesting the amendment to Waqf Act reflects BJP’s ‘injustice’ to one community in India. “We believe in a secular India, where all communities are respected, and all voices are heard,” she concluded.

The Waqf (Amendment) Bill seeks to overhaul the Waqf Act, 1995, by renaming it the Unified Waqf Management, Empowerment, Efficiency, and Development Act. Key provisions include greater representation of Muslim women and non-Muslims in Waqf boards, the establishment of separate boards for Bohras and Aghakhanis, and enhanced oversight over Waqf property management. The bill also aims to streamline the registration of Waqf properties through a central portal, while removing the power of boards to independently decide if a property is Waqf, a move critics argue undermines community autonomy.​

Reported By: Tamal Saha     Place: Kolkata     Nov 28, 2024 12:21 pm




Place : Kolkata     Reported By : Tamal Saha     28-11-2024 12:21:38 pm

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee sharply criticized the Central Government’s proposed amendments to the Waqf Act, 1995, calling it an attack on federalism, secularism, and the rights of minority communities. The bill, which aims to increase accountability in the management of Waqf boards, proposes significant changes, including the mandatory inclusion of Muslim women and non-Muslims in these bodies.

Speaking in the West Bengal Assembly, Banerjee expressed her opposition to the bill, saying the state government had not been consulted on the changes. “The state government has not been consulted at all,” she remarked, adding that such a major issue should involve input from state governments that manage Waqf boards.

The Chief Minister warned that if the bill becomes law, it would effectively “destroy” the institution of Waqf, which has existed since British colonial times. “Waqf properties also have Hindus residing in them, and some properties have been donated by other communities. These are shared resources,” Banerjee said, underlining the historical and pluralistic nature of Waqf institutions.
Banerjee also criticized the bill’s centralization of power over Waqf boards, describing it as “anti-federal.” She called it a deliberate attempt to “malign a particular section” and deprive Muslims of their rights. “In this bill, the rights of Muslims are being snatched away,” she stated, drawing attention to how the bill seeks to alter the governance structure of Waqf boards without sufficient consultation with stakeholders.

The contentious bill was proposed to be taken up during the winter session but sources indicate, there could be appeal made on Friday by the Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) which is in custody of the bill, seeking extension of time till the last day of the budget session of 2025. The come following a stormy meeting of the panel marked by a brief walkout from opposition members on November 27 over disagreements.

On the issue of alleged atrocities against Hindus in Bangladesh, Mamata Banerjee expressed solidarity with those affected, stating, “We cannot tolerate atrocities against any community.” She referred to her conversations with religious leaders in Bengal, including the ISKCON head, and reiterated that her government supports the central government in addressing international issues, particularly related to what’s unfolding in Bangladesh. “I have spoken to the ISKCON head here in Kolkata. We can’t tolerate any atrocity against any community. But Bangladesh is a different country and the Government of India has to take a decision. Whatever the Union Government decides we will support it. There’s no difference on this. We will not tolerate any atrocity against community” she added in the backdrop of arrest of priest Chinmoy Krishna Das in Bangladesh that has stoked diplomatic tensions between India and Bangladesh -the two neighbours.


While she stressed on solidarity with the people affected in Bangladesh, but Banerjee equally stressed on the need for domestic policies to reflect India’s commitment to secularism. “If there’s any atrocity against any community in another country, we speak about. So why should we not speak it, if happening in our own country” Mamata Banerjee questioned while suggesting the amendment to Waqf Act reflects BJP’s ‘injustice’ to one community in India. “We believe in a secular India, where all communities are respected, and all voices are heard,” she concluded.

The Waqf (Amendment) Bill seeks to overhaul the Waqf Act, 1995, by renaming it the Unified Waqf Management, Empowerment, Efficiency, and Development Act. Key provisions include greater representation of Muslim women and non-Muslims in Waqf boards, the establishment of separate boards for Bohras and Aghakhanis, and enhanced oversight over Waqf property management. The bill also aims to streamline the registration of Waqf properties through a central portal, while removing the power of boards to independently decide if a property is Waqf, a move critics argue undermines community autonomy.​

Top Posts

1.

Air India Flight AI171 Crashes Shortly After Take-Off in Ahmedabad...

An Air India aircraft bound for London’s Gatwick Airport crashed shortly after taking off from Ahm... Read more
2.

Muhammad Yunus Claims PM Modi Ignored Request to Restrain Hasina’s Political Messaging from Indian...

Bangladesh’s interim government chief, Muhammad Yunus, has alleged that Indian Prime Minister Nare... Read more
3.

Winds of Change in Maharashtra? Raj Thackeray’s Meeting with Devendra Fadnavis Sparks Speculation ...

In a development that could reshape political equations in Maharashtra, Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (... Read more
4.

Opposition Accuses UP Government of Hiding True Death Toll in Maha Kumbh Stampede; Cites BBC Report...

The Opposition has launched a scathing attack on the Yogi Adityanath-led Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP... Read more
5.

Four Railway Officials Suspended After Dilapidated Train Assigned to BSF Troops for Amarnath Yatra D...

The Ministry of Railways has suspended four officials following widespread outrage over the allocati... Read more

LATEST NEWS

1.

Air India Flight AI171 Crashes Shortly After Take-Off in Ahmedabad...

An Air India aircraft bound for London’s Gatwick Airport crashed shortly after taking off from Ahm... Read more
2.

Muhammad Yunus Claims PM Modi Ignored Request to Restrain Hasina’s Political Messaging from Indian...

Bangladesh’s interim government chief, Muhammad Yunus, has alleged that Indian Prime Minister Nare... Read more
3.

Winds of Change in Maharashtra? Raj Thackeray’s Meeting with Devendra Fadnavis Sparks Speculation ...

In a development that could reshape political equations in Maharashtra, Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (... Read more
4.

Opposition Accuses UP Government of Hiding True Death Toll in Maha Kumbh Stampede; Cites BBC Report...

The Opposition has launched a scathing attack on the Yogi Adityanath-led Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP... Read more
5.

Four Railway Officials Suspended After Dilapidated Train Assigned to BSF Troops for Amarnath Yatra D...

The Ministry of Railways has suspended four officials following widespread outrage over the allocati... Read more
6.

Maheshtala Violence: 40 Arrested, Police Personnel Injured, Prohibitory Orders Imposed...

At least 40 people have been arrested following violent clashes in Bengal’s Maheshtala, that left ... Read more

Top Videos