“Don’t attract unnecessary attention…”: SMCH Advisory Criticized for Misplaced Focus After Kolkata RG Kar Doctor’s Rape and Murder

An advisory issued by Silchar Medical College and Hospital (SMCH) in Assam has stoked a massive controversy, particularly from its Junior Doctors Association terming it “outrageous”. The advisory, prompted by the rape and murder of a PGT doctor at R.G. Kar Medical College in Kolkata, has drawn criticism for its focus on female staff and its perceived shortcomings in addressing broader security concerns.

Issued by the principal-cum-chief superintendent, Dr. Bhaskar Gupta, the advisory was intended to enhance the safety of female doctors, students, and other healthcare workers. It recommends that women avoid poorly lit, isolated areas and situations where they are alone, especially during late hours. The advisory also urges women to adhere to hostel regulations, avoid off-campus excursions at night, and remain emotionally composed and alert while on duty. “Female doctors, students, and staff should, as much as possible, avoid situations where they are alone. Refrain from leaving hostel or lodging rooms during night hours unless absolutely necessary, with prior information to the concerned authority," stated the advisory.

“While on duty you should be well composed emotionally, remain alert about the surroundings and should graciously interact with the public, so that you don't attract unnecessary attention from unscrupulous people,” reads the advisory asking female doctors and students to refrain from attracting unnecessary attention from unscrupulous people.

In addition, the advisory stated that female doctors and students must avoid situations when they are alone. "Female doctors, students, and staff should, as much as possible, avoid situations where they are alone. Refrain from leaving hostel or lodging rooms during night hours unless absolutely necessary, with prior information to the concerned authority,” it added.

The advisory also suggested that female staff ensure they have a means of making emergency contact and avoid interacting with individuals who appear suspicious. The principal emphasized that the advisory was issued "in the greater interest of doctors, students, and staff members of Silchar Medical College and Hospital, with special emphasis on female members."

The Junior Doctors Association at SMCH has condemned the advisory, calling it "outrageous" and accusing it of unfairly targeting female doctors. They argue that it fails to address key security issues and that its language is troubling. In response to the criticism, Dr. Gupta announced late Tuesday that the existing advisory would be withdrawn and replaced with a new one. "We will cancel it and issue a new advisory tomorrow," he confirmed.

Students and staff have expressed their dissatisfaction through protests, demanding enhanced security measures. Their actionable demands include improved lighting in hospital areas, round-the-clock security, and better facilities for doctors, and increased CCTV surveillance. The tragic incident in Kolkata has led to widespread protests within the medical community and prompted a Central Bureau of Investigation probe ordered by the Calcutta High Court.​